Buyers guides
You are looking at: Home : Buyers guides

Buyers' Guide - GPS

What will a GPS do for you that a good old fashioned map and compass won’t?


Posted: 21 October 2005
by Dave Mycroft

What is a GPS?

GPS is an acronym for Global Positioning System. Put simply, in the outdoor world, GPS refers to a hand held receiver for a satellite-based radio positioning systems that provides 24 hour three-dimensional position, velocity and time information anywhere on or near the surface of the Earth (and sometimes off the earth).


How do they work?

24 (and a few spares for redundancy) satellites constantly circle the earth in 12 hour orbit patterns that give complete coverage of the earths surface. These satellites transmit signals to receivers on the ground giving the satellites location and the time. All the satellites transmissions are synchronised to ensure they send at the same time. As the signals travel at the speed of light they reach a GPS receiver at slightly different times depending on their distance from the receiver. The receiver determines the distance from the satellite from the time the signal takes to reach it. When the receiver has calculated the distance from at least four GPS satellites, it can calculate its position in three dimensions. This enables the receiver to give an accurate longitude, latitude and altitude.For a receiver to find its position it has to have a line of sight to the satellites, and this is where problems can occur. If you’re in woodland or amongst tall buildings it may be difficult to get an accurate signal or even any signal at all, though the receivers have improved in this area over recent years. Obviously the more satellites a receiver can obtain signals from the more accurate the “fix” will be.

Types of GPS
Two major manufacturers dominate the handheld GPS market, Garmin and Magellan, but in reality they’re essentially the same products in different shells– as are a number of emerging smaller manufacturers’ products. While there’s little difference between equivalent models from different manufacturers there’s a great deal of difference between “starter” models and more advanced units.


Basic Models –
The new generation of basic models are now available for well under £100. Typically these will use the signals from up to 12 satellites to give a basic level of output limited to displaying your position and direction of travel. Position can usually be displayed in a choice of format including latitude/longitude or grid reference, and most GPS units ship with a base map to show your position (base maps installed usually depend on the country the unit was designed to ship to – eg. US models will have a base map of the USA). Any ability to store your walking routes in will be limited in number and restricted to the receiver’s internal memory and can’t be transferred to a computer for saving.

Advanced Models –
Advanced models expand on the feature set of basic models. As well as giving your position they’re designed to allow you to keep permanent records of your travels. You should expect to be able to save several hundred routes and locations internally, and be able to transfer them to digital mapping software. The high end models also come complete with improved and on-screen mapping and a colour screen.

PDA GPS –
Many modern Personal Digital Assistants have the ability to combine with either an internal or external GPS receiver. Rather than using a typical hand held sized receiver they use small Bluetooth based units which send your position via radio waves to digital mapping software on the PDA. One of the main advantages of a PDA based system is the ability to see your position on a much larger screen marked on an accurate digital map (eg OS 1:25,000). Routes and waypoints can be transferred to and from a computer using synchronisation software usually supplied with the PDA. The downsides of PDA based systems are the extra weight compared to a stand alone unit, and battery consumption.

Integrated GPS
Manufacturers are now starting to integrate GPS receivers into watches. Due to the limitations of a typical watch display the feature set is usually very limited. Expect positioning, and possibly an electronic compass, and in high end models the ability to save one or two routes/waypoints, but not a lot more.

Functions and Features

It’s the functions and features of the different models that really sets one apart from another. How much you want each feature should be the main factor in choosing which one to buy.

Position
All units will give you an accurate location in three dimensions. You can choose between international grids such as longitude/latitude and the national grid of the country you’re in – e.g. UK NGR


Direction/bearing
All units will give you the option to take a bearing between your position and a known point. This feature can vary from obtaining a bearing to a grid reference you enter, to the ability to reverse an entire walk using bearings from point to point.

Waypoints
A Waypoint is simply a place whose position you wish to record. You can use waypoints to record points of interest, places you took photographs from or important deviations in a route. Entire walking routes can be made up of a series of waypoints, and advanced GPS receivers and PDA based systems can often store thousands of waypoints. Basic units will be able to store waypoints internally, and a recall facility to view the waypoint positions. Advanced units will expand on this by allowing the export and import of waypoints between the receiver and digital mapping software on a computer.

Route and track storage
One of the best features of having a GPS is the ability to store a record of exactly where you’ve been. At it’s most basic level this means that should the weather close in you can use the record to retrace your route in safety. At the other end of the scale connecting a GPS to digital mapping software lets you check out routes on your computer once you get home, or even plan a route at home and transfer the route to your GPS for following once on the hill. Different manufacturers use different terminology, but essentially a route is a series of connected waypoints, whereas a track is a recording in real time of the route you take.

Altimeter
Although not particularly useful in the UK, an altimeter comes into its own when in the Alps or similar mountain environments. Many alpine routes require direction changes at known altitudes, and in reduced visibility an altimeter can literally be a life saver.

Other functions
Most GPS receivers will include additional features such as the local time and the speed of travel. While occasionally useful for working out how much longer you have to go before the end of a route these are minor features and pretty much universal.

Digital Mapping

The ability to combine a GPS with digital mapping software is where GPS really comes into its own. Using products from Memory Map, Anquet, Tracklogs and Fugawi you can display the output from GPS recorded routes using high quality digital OS maps on your PC (Mac versions due some time). This feature isn’t available in basic GPS units, which don’t have an import/export facility. Depending on the software (eg. MM, Anquet etc) you can overlay your routes on standard, aerial or 3D maps, or do the process in reverse and plan the route on your PC then export the route to the GPS.

PDA based GPS has the ability to show the same OS maps on screen on the PDA, with your GPS located position marked on the map. As with advanced stand alone GPS units, you can transfer routes and tracks in either direction.

Accessories

Like most modern gadgets, buying the unit is often only the start of things. Once you’ve got your GPS you find there’s a whole catalogue of extras you can buy. One of the most useful accessories is undoubtedly a connection cable for linking the GPS to a PC. Beyond that you need to think about waterproofing and spare batteries. In general a stand alone GPS should be able to cope with a weekend away without needing a battery change, but if you’re looking at PDA based systems don’t expect your batteries to last more than 6-8 hours of constant use.

How To Chooses your GPS

So how do you choose which GPS to buy? Well with the wide range on offer it’s sometimes hard to differentiate. The secret is deciding what you want to use it for. If you just want it as an additional safety device in case you need to check your position, but most of the time it will sit in your pack, then you don’t really need to look beyond the basic models. If you want the ability to transfer routes to a computer and use digital mapping the choice comes down to a combination of factors including weight/battery life and the number of routes and tracks you need to store.If you prefer to have an on-screen OS map then you need to look at the high end stand alone GPS units or a PDA based solution.

Model Price Way
pts
Rts strd Tracks
track
pts stored
Batt Batt life PC Conn Weight excl batteries Altimeter/
compass
Extra
features
OM rating
Magellan
SporTrak
£174.95 500 20 2000 AA 14 hrs 9 pin
serial
173gm No/Yes Waterproof
Pc cable
colour screen
Expensive for the feature set
Garmin eTrex £88.84 500 1 1536 AA 22 hrs 9 pin
serial
150.3gm No/No Waterproof/
PC cable
Good value PC compatible model
Garmin
eTrex Summit
£149.85 500 20 3000 AA 22 hrs 9 pin
serial
150.3gm Yes/Yes Waterproof/
takes additional maps/
PC cable
Well established favourite, ideally suited to combining with a PC Great for Alpine use
Garmin
Geko 101
£73.84 250 0 300 AAA 12 hrs N/A 88.0gm No/No Waterproof Reasonable basic starter unit, but 201 is better value
Garmin
Geko 201
£99.99 250 20 10000 AAA 12 hrs 9 pin
serial
88.0gm No/No Waterproof Best Value for UK use
Fortuna
GPS Smart
£79.99 3120 20 3120 AAA 14hrs Bluetooth or serial/
mini USB
110.0gm No/No Can link to
PDA or PC
Average performance, alternatives provide better value
Lowrance
iFinder Go
£79.99 1000 100 100/
10000
AA 48hrs N/A 151.9gm Yes/No Waterproof Good value basic model with reasonable memory

More Help and Advice

There are several good online sites for further information on GPS. For PDA based systems www.totalpda.co.uk provides a full range of PDAs and GPS add-ons. www.pocketgps.co.uk provides comparison charts between all the popular makes and models along with details of PC connection cables and accessories.

Hopefully this article will have given you some basic pointers. The good news is that there's a load more advice on OUTDOORSmagic:

  • Ask on the gear forum about general issues or specific items.
  • Check the member reviews section for user experiences of kit.
  • See OM editorial reviews on the front of the site for our impressions.
  • Ask Richard Gear if you have a specific question you need answering.

  • Previous article
    Lightweight podcast pioneer receiving rave reviews
    Next article
    Walking Route - Western Edge - The Peak District


    TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle

    Related Content

    Related Products


    Discuss this story

    Has anyone any experience of gps units that work with a mobile phone via bluetooth? I've got a Nokia 6630 and I know there's software around, but I'm not sure whether it's more how to avoid speed cameras/find your way around the M25 type software.

    Not that I really need a GPS as I'm the pround possessor of a pair of M&S Directional walking trousers with built in compass ;-)

    Posted: 21/10/2005 at 13:56

    Your main problem will be that a GPS receiver for the 6630 will cost the same as a decent low end purpose built handheld GPS.

    Posted: 21/10/2005 at 15:52

    There are some great Bluetooth gps receivers around that work well with mobile phones. GlobalSat, Socket, Emtac to name just three. In my experience, getting these to connect with your phone is very easy.

    Software-wise, there are many driving direction applications available - TomTom and Wayfinder are two of the more popular. Not only will these provide A to B driving directions across most of Western Europe, but will often include points-of-interest (so you can find the nearest filling-station or cinema) and are starting to include safety camera databases. PocketGPSWorld.com also has a good safety camera database.

    For outdoors walking/hiking use there are a few apps that will basically record your route. However, these are not anywhere near as sophisticated in capability as you'd find in a dedicated GPS unit.

    For something a little different, you may want to take a look at ViewRanger (http://www.viewranger.com). This brand new application runs on mobile phones and provides a panoramic display showing the landscape horizon - and labels the hills, lakes, woodland, etc. within that vista. It uses a Bluetooth GPS unit to provide positioning to the phone & application. (Disclosure: I work for the company developing ViewRanger.)

    For walking, we've found that putting the Bluetooth GPS unit in your pocket or rucksack is usually fine and it will still get a good satellite fix. Under very dense tree canopy, then the accuracy of the BT GPS can vary but the accuracy and quality has improved a lot, and will continue to do so, in these types of situations.

    I don't know how the performance of Bluetooth GPS units compares against dedicated handheld GPS units in these dense canopy cases. Perhaps it's time Garmin added a Bluetooth commmunication capability to some of their GPS handhelds!

    Posted: 21/10/2005 at 17:54

    See more comments...
    Talkback: Buyers' Guide - GPS

    First Name:
    Last Name:
    Nickname:
    Email:
    Security Image:
    Enter the code shown:

    I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct: