Talkback: 'Obesity, Depression And Hill Walking' - One Brave Blog

18 messages
08/03/2012 at 20:06
Quite taken with her OMM 25L sack review, actually: http://walkingwithfatty.blogspot.com/2012/02/omnipresent-mountain-magic-omm-25l.html
I've used a 10L OMM sack for years - I find it keeps things nice and light for something like a day's walk. For years before that I used to hulk around seemingly everything but the kitchen sink in a 30L bag 'just in case' :o)
09/03/2012 at 07:34
This is a deeply moving blog from a courageous person who is determined to overcome her private demons, and I urge all members of this forum to read and reflect on it.

Her story supports my long-held belief that the Government's policy of encouraging us to take up sport for the sake of our health is misguided. The emphasis seems to be on organized sport, but relatively few people can participate and enjoy competitive games much beyond their mid-forties. Recreations such as walking, cycling and swimming can be life-long activities as Waldo and I can attest. I've just turned eighty and still go backpacking with my twenty year-old son, and can normally match him stride for stride except when descending steep trails on loose rock.

It's possible to spend a small fortune on gear as readers of this forum will know, but walking can cost very little. My late father was a keen walker all his life and the only item of gear that he possessed was a cheap canvas rucksack. He wore Lotus veltschoon shoes, a pair of old flannel trousers and other discarded items from his regular wardrobe. When it rained, he put on a plastic mac and a flat cap and cheerfully expected to get wet. He was thrifty, but not hard-up, and he didn't see the need for expensive gear. Before WW1 it was quite normal for walkers to wear their every-day clothes of a stiff collar, tie and a bowler hat!

Hugh

09/03/2012 at 07:51

A thought-provoking and stirring read, I agree. Good stuff.

As an aside, I hadn't prteviously come across that Nietzsche quote: All truly great thoughts are conceived by walking

Edited: 09/03/2012 at 07:53
09/03/2012 at 09:54
It was good until sexuality was mentioned, what's that got to do with anything
09/03/2012 at 11:12

It's her blog, Mick, why shouldn't she talk about it?

09/03/2012 at 11:18
I don't get why people who don't want their sexuality to be an issue are prepared to tell the world about it. Why not keep it private.
09/03/2012 at 11:24
Why not keep private your opinion on whether someone in their online diary should talk about their sexuality?
09/03/2012 at 11:25

Its like that program (embarrassing bodies) clearly they aint embarrassed otherwise why go on national TV to show everyone your turnip shaped penis or 3rd butt cheek !

09/03/2012 at 11:27
Metric Kate wrote (see)
Why not keep private your opinion on whether someone in their online diary should talk about their sexuality?

I will.
09/03/2012 at 11:34
That woman might be a bit overweight but she looks as strong as an ox, and regardless of what she thinks of herself she is very strong minded as well, hitting the hills on her own when she knows how hard it will be, then blogging her struggle in the way she as. Inspirational.
09/03/2012 at 14:11

"I hate being passed at pace by cheerful souls whilst I am wheezing like an over loaded pack horse and sweating like a pig.  I hate it that I am not the one passing me with great bounding foot sure leaps. I hate feeling like I don’t belong."

No sense from me that overweight people don't 'belong' in the hills; there may be fitness issues that Nina describes above that make it harder for them to get into the hills, but I'd be very supportive of anyone I saw struggling against their weight to get out and get into the hills.

I think the comments that you do see about obsessing about lightweight kit are referring to those of us who are carrying perhaps one or two stone more than we 'should', and based on an assumption that most of those people could lose them without too much trouble.  But there's a big difference between a stone or two, and being twice as heavy as a 'healthy BMI'would suggest; that's a much harder challenge.

So, kudos to Nina for getting out there, and fighting her demons.

Edited: 09/03/2012 at 14:14
09/03/2012 at 18:32

Addick wrote (see)
It was good until sexuality was mentioned, what's that got to do with anything

Metric Kate wrote (see)

It's her blog, Mick, why shouldn't she talk about it?


Addick wrote (see)
I don't get why people who don't want their sexuality to be an issue are prepared to tell the world about it. Why not keep it private.

I'm guessing she wants to marry her partner, which is a public act: "formalise her...monogamous relationship"

If someone who is forbidden from marrying started lecturing me that the act of me choosing my of life partner was a "grotesque subversion of a universally accepted human right" I might feel a little miffed.

03/04/2012 at 10:23
Thank you very much to those of you who have taken the time to read my blog and leave constructive feed back and criticism. Going public for lack of a better expression about my weight was actually a lot, lot harder than being openly gay and it the fact that I mentioned my sexuality was to set the context of my post.

I am not going to indulge in mindless and bigoted sniping on this forum or any other save to say that the suggestion that anyone should have to hide their sexuality if they don't want to have it criticised is the height of senseless stupidity and demonstrates a very closed mind.
03/04/2012 at 11:36
It was a great read Nina - honest and open, can't fault that.
26/04/2013 at 14:46
An amazing read and truly inspirational. I would love to get started, did a little hill on new years day, but need the clothes and thats where I struggle because outerwear shops don't sell much over a size 16. Has anyone any idea? Andrea
26/04/2013 at 15:38

You don't need anything overly technical to get started. A quick look at Sports Direct and Field and Trek (same company) suggests that for example base layers are available in size 22 and in 3XL. There are some softshell jackets in 18, waterproofs in 20. Trousers in 20.

Some sort of tracksuit bottoms are fine in most conditions.

Mountainwarehouse has softshell jackets in size 22.

I expect there is more choice online than in the shops, they often don't stock all sizes.

26/04/2013 at 16:18

I struggle because outerwear shops don't sell much over a size 16. Has anyone any idea?

TK Maxx often have outdoor stuff in larger sizes; my guess is that the larger sizes don't often sell, so they end up in TKM.  Lucky for some!

Edited: 26/04/2013 at 16:21
26/04/2013 at 16:24

Don't spend too much Andie. If you start walking regularly, you won't be a size 16 for long.

Good luck.


 

Your say
email image
18 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions