Sunday 21 March 2010 | Personalise | Help  
 FORUM REVIEWS
 
Related Categories:
Tents \ Two-person
Related Products:
Terra Nova Laser
 

 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
Ahhhhhhh which tent!
1 to 7 of 7 messagesTo post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
 
Show/hide user stats
Hey people, help me out here, Im trying to work out what 2 man light (under 2kg) tent to buy for a six month trekking extravaganza in nepal and pakistan. Here's my shortlist:

Stephenson's 2R
Hilleberg Nallo 2
Tarptent Squall 2
Terra Nova Laser

Worst possible conditions would be about
-15C with 40mph winds and snow. I also will be camping in heat, probably about 20C at night at the most.

Which one would you have? money isn't an issue
Show/hide user stats
The stephenson. Lightest, warmest, coolest, fastest to put up, and lots of space. I have one, having looked at all the others, and have never regretted the choice.
Show/hide user stats
I've just read some info about the Stephenson tents and it does make me wonder how it is that with all their R & D budgets companies like TNF and MHW etc... make the tents they do and not follow Stephenson's example and build a tent that is stronger than the moon, lighter than helium, more spacious than a warehouse and yet only needs 2 poles and 3 pegs!?!?!

Surely if a particular design was that good then everyone would be doing it?
Show/hide user stats
I remember a Dilbert cartoon about that - an engineer has a great idea, which his boss discards on the basis that 'if nobody else does that, it can't be any good'. A design that requires laser cutting (not a mass-market technique), 7001 poles (I think) - again, not a standard pole material, and the users have to seam-seal it themselves, may not appeal to the mass-market crowd.

Also, the design has some limitations:
1) The material used (parachute cloth) doesn't many US fire regs (an absolute no-no for mass manufacture).
2) The overall design relies on users being 'sensible'. Jack Stephenson alledgedly used to interview prospective customers to ensure they knew what they were getting. If you abuse the tent, in particular not following his (very simple but quite rigid) instructions for putting it up, then you risk damaging it. It takes <2mins to put up even in a storm, so I don't find this a problem.
3) The poles need looked after - they're extremely thin-walled, but much larger diameter, so once up they're very strong, but if you apply a point load they can be broken. I suspect a mass manufacturer would be faced with a lot of returns for broken poles from mis-use (already a problem for some tent manufacturers with existing thick-walled poles).
4) There's no warranty. You have (I think) 28 days to check it for problems and return it, and thereafter they will repair it for you (at $50/hr) or tell you how to do it. When a fox attacked mine and tore a bit, they sent me the repair materials for free and talked me through the repair on the phone. Frankly, for me a warranty is useless as I'm rarely in a location where I could take advantage of it.

That said, mine has stood up to 70mph+ winds (nr Mt Cook, NZ), torrential rain, 40C+ heat (oz outback) and c.150 nights continual usage on the PCT including blizzards and c.20nights in the snow. They've also been used on Denali and assorted other high altitude peaks. For a 1.3kg tent, there's nothing close to it. My next tent will undoubtedly be another Stephenson.
Show/hide user stats
Stove man.........im sold!
Show/hide user stats
Suggestions if you get one:

1) Definitely go for the side "windows" - much cooler and only c.60g more. Basically, huge side panels (1m x 0.7m) with mozzie netting that can be unzipped. Done up, the tent is the same as the normal one (ie insulated).

2) If you're frequently going to be in windy places, the wind stabilizers (like vanogs TBS) might be worth it. I don't have these so the tent jumps around a bit in high wind, although Stephenson claim that its structurally ok to 100mph or so without stabilizers, and 160mph with.

3) Definitely go for the large door.

4) Don't go for light green. Its luminous. I made that mistake.

5) Plan ahead - it takes them weeks or months to be made; worth calling them and ask what the current wait would be. They sometimes have some in stock.

There's various pictures of the tent on my website homepage.ntlworld.com/davidtoms
Show/hide user stats
For my money I'd go with the H'berg nallo 2 or as a last minute contender
copy and paste this link.

http://www.lightwave.uk.com/en/tent_t1ultraxt.php

good luck.


 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > GearForum jump  
Support our sponsors
 
Support our sponsors
 
Travel Partners
 
Offers, Competitions and Promotions
Win Free Stuff

Win Bridgedale socks
6 pairs of Bridgedale Endurance Trail Ultra Light Socks to be won
Win a £100 gift token
Win £100 to spend at Ultimate Adventure Hardware
Win a pair of TEVA Itunda
Revolutionizing the sports sandal with a brand new product
Win a pair of Steep GT's
Comfort, style, durability & practicality from Zamberlan
Win 1 of 6 Walkabout Satchels
Amazing National Geographic bags worth £145 each

Advertorial: Craigdon Mountain Sports
Celebrating 25 years of Craigdon
Advertorial: Yew Clothing
You love the outdoors. You can show that by choosing Yew Clothing
Advertorial: GTC Satellite Phones
Heading into the unknown? Stay in touch with a satellite phone
Instant Expert Guide To...
Trail Running


GPS Help and User Guide