active network: BikeMagic : Golfmagic : OutdoorsMagic : RCUK : Visordown  
Welcome to OUTDOORSmagic
Forgot your password?
Have an account?
  •  
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Blogs
  • Features
  • Gallery
  • Routes
  • Forum
  • Shop
  • Ask Us
Join  
RSS  
Advertise  
Blog  
Outdoors News  
Gear News  
Travel News  
Jackets  
Other Clothing  
Footwear  
Packs  
Tents  
Sleeping  
Other Equipment  
Gear News  
Buy online  
Classifieds  
Local shops  
Forum  
Outdoor News Blog  
Editorial musings  
Gear Blog  
Thoughts from the Outdoors  
Outdoor Features  
Hill skills  
Health and fitness  
Travel features  
Gear features  
Add image  
Latest images  
OM Members' album  
All albums  
Front page  
User guide  
Gallery Forum  
Walking  
Scrambling  
Meets and Partners forum  
Search routes  
Map a route  
Routes forum  
Latest Posts  
New discussions  
Hot Threads  
Trip Reports  
New Member Introductions  
Soapbox  
Walking and Climbing  
Gear  
Meets and Partners  
Starting out?  
Travel  
Lakeland 100 Chat  
tgo magazine live letters archive  
Gallery  
GPS help and advice  
Classifieds Section  
Online Shopping  
Second Hand  
Local Shops  
Ask a gear question  
See gear answers  
Forum
You are looking at: Home : Forum :

Gear

Climbing Helmets
 
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum TopicsHelp | Settings | Public Profile
 Search forum: 
Climbing Helmets
In a pickle? Black Diamond Half Dome, Petzl Elios or Ecrin Roc
spacer image
1 to 11 of 11 messages
spacer image
 
Show/hide user stats
Jerome Conreen
06/01/07 18:57
 Lowland rambler 110 forum posts 9 photos 1 review
What helmets do people use? I know that its probably only going to get used a few times a year, but after reading some stuff on the BMC site and in the reviews section, I'm confused.
The outdoor shop are currently doing the Black Diamond Half Dome for £30, but I'm getting conflicting info as to how safe it is.
The Ecrin Roc, seems to be popular, but I don't really want to spend £45-50 on somthing that is going to spend a lot of its life on a shelf.
That brings me to the Elios I haven't found a lot of info on this one at all.

Help please?
 Send to friend
Edited: 06/01/07 19:01
Show/hide user stats
Dave Gilden
06/01/07 19:09
 Lowland rambler 62 forum posts 1 bookmark
all mainstream climbing hlemets are going to be UIAA tested and so safe for the first strike they receive
Any reason why you aren't considering the CAMP Rocstar?
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Jerome Conreen
06/01/07 19:14
 Lowland rambler 110 forum posts 9 photos 1 review
I haven't really looked at the Rocstar? Will have a look thanks.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Ddyrchafedig Gyrrwr (Beic Modur)
06/01/07 20:27
 Winter Mountaineer 12396 forum posts 55 photos 1 article 3 reviews 9 bookmarks


As I use helmets for both climbing and caving, IMHO you can't go wrong with Petzl, As you may realise, when caving, we wear them for extended periods and I have found them to be the most comfortable.


 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Pete B
06/01/07 20:56
 Lowland rambler 89 forum posts 2 photos 6 reviews
Try on the helmets you are interested in before buying as if you don't find it comfortable you are less likely to wear it.

The Ecrin Roc and Camp Rockstar are all ABS shell helmets and durable but are heavier. The Grivel Salamander, Black diamond half dome and Petzl Elios are lighter with slightly thinner outer and a foam for impact absorption.
Petzl Meteor 3 is lighter still but has a even thinner outer and foam for impact absorption but is designed to only take one good impact.

I think all helmet manufacture say you bin the helmet after it has taken an impact.

I use a Grivel Salamander a bit more expensive at £50 but I find mine comfy.
Also look at this link
 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Gneiss Boots
07/01/07 12:40
Fantastic article at link Pete. Very though provoking. I had been musing about replacing my too old PETZL helmet but had been fobbing it off and buying more new gear instead - not any more. Old one is going in the bin and I am going to get a new one now.
 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Richard G.
07/01/07 15:03
Camp Rockstar is on offer (23 quid) at GoOutdoors at the mo.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Air Vice Marshall Tarka, Otter Bomber...
07/01/07 16:19
 Lowland rambler 908 forum posts 2 photos 3 reviews
Petzl's Ecrin Roc is well worth the money. It's bomb proof (unlike some 'lightweight' models that need to binned if they take a knock - like bike helmets) and is the comfiest helmet I've used (sadly it got nicked/lost). I use the Elios now (GoOutdoors were doing them for under 30 quid before Xmas) but after a couple of hours it can feel a little uncomfortable, unlike the Ecrin.
Regardless of what you get, make sure you write your name, tel. no. and the date you bought in in marker pen on the inside - replace it after about 5 years whether it's had knocks or not as the materials can deteriorate and weaken.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Ddyrchafedig Gyrrwr (Beic Modur)
07/01/07 18:50
 Winter Mountaineer 12396 forum posts 55 photos 1 article 3 reviews 9 bookmarks


Funnily enough, I picked up my new Ecrin Roc today.

I got it discounted for £40 as a special favour from a friend, so I am not able to say where as Petzl would apparently get funny over it and maybe stop supplying him.

I have now got to invalidate the warranty by drilling holes in it to fit the lamp bracket!

 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Simon Chaplin
07/01/07 19:27
I've got a Petzl Ecrin Roc and have used this climbing, winter mountaineering and caving and ifnd it extremely comfortable. I also have a Petzl Myo 5 and this fits all the right places to make it comfortable as well.

Paid £30 but bought it a couple of years ago. Well worth the money.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Original Outdoors Guy
07/01/07 19:58
 Lowland rambler 773 forum posts 1 bookmark
Another vote for the Ecrin Roc. Fits well, solid fastenings and can take one or two minor scrapes (my opinion, not a validation!)

A couple of very nice people have just donated a load of these for the team:

http://www.headtorches.com/headtorches_rechargeable.html

They are absolutely massive, but fit well on the Ecrin. As does my Myolite..
 Send to friend
Edited: 07/01/07 20:00

 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
  
 

Change stats view
spacer image
bookmarkMake external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
spacer image
Forum jump  
Spacer image
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Shopping
Berkshire Outdoor Leisure
Fox's Outdoor
Springfield Camping
Cave and Crag
E-outdoor
EDZ Layering
Trek Plus
The Photon Shop
Trekmates
Park Cameras
The Outdoor Shop
Ellis Brigham Mountain Sports
Latest on the site
Arc'teryx Photo Comp At ShAFF
There's a £500 plus a bunch of kit for budding amateir adventure photographers in this unique competition.
Fort William Mountain Festival: Incoming - Video
Under a week to go before this year's Fort William celebration of mountain culture and here's the showreel trailer!
Weekend Mountain Weather Outlook
All the weather information you need to plan your outdoors weekend.
  • OM On Tour In The Sunny North East
  • Walna Scar Closed To Motor Vehicles
Competitions

There are currently no comps running on OutdoorsMagic
Sign up to our twitter feed
Promotions

New to Cotswold Outdoor
Rab Microlight Alpine Jackets for men and women
Dog day afternoons
Activities for you and your dog courtesy of Sainsbury's Finance
Facebook

Become a fan of OutdoorsMagic

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Newsletter

Sign up to our free newsletter

Meet some partners

Meet partners in our forum

Other Immediate Media Sites

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • MadeForMums

Active

  • AVReview
  • BIKEmagic
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • RoadCyclingUK
  • Visordown

Our eCommerce Platform

About OutdoorsMagic

  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Forums

  • Trip Reports
  • New Member Introductions
  • Soapbox
  • Walking and Climbing
  • Gear
  • Meets and Partners
  • Starting out?
  • Travel
  • Lakeland 100 Chat
  • tgo magazine live letters archive
  • Gallery
  • GPS help and advice
  • Classifieds Section

Reviews

  • Jackets
  • Other Clothing
  • Footwear
  • Packs
  • Tents
  • Sleeping
  • Other Equipment

Home

  • Join OutdoorsMagic
  • Advertise with us
  • Take our articles (RSS)

News

Blogs

Features

Gallery

Routes

Shop

Ask Us

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms + conditions
  • Advertise with us

© Immediate Media Company Ltd 2011. This website is owned and published by Immediate Media Company Limited. www.immediatemedia.co.uk