OUTDOORSmagic
 Home » Forum > GearWednesday 20 August 2008 | Help  
Prizes to be won!
Click below to enter
Free weekly newsletter!
Join OUTDOORSmagic now
Members can use the forum and gallery, receive a weekly newsletter and are eligible to win great prizes!
why join?  
Travel Partners
Travel Partners
Exodus
Inghams
Explore!
eVent technology
eVent
Latest Reviews
6881 Total Reviews
Gallery Rated Image
Alone In The Wilderness
by Jon Shack
 FORUM REVIEWS
 
Related Categories:
Media \ Art and Magazines

 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
Mountaineering books -recommendations
Please...
41 to 54 of 54 messages. Page: 1  2  3  To post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
Show/hide user stats
Beckoning Silence is the one for me as pulls in many different events around Joe Simpsons life into the main story of the Eiger climb.
Show/hide user stats
Personally I thought The Beckoning Silence was hard to get into, and took me ages to read. Game of Ghosts was better, Touching the Void pretty damn good :-)

Currently reading Bear Grylls' (sp?) Facing Up, nice easy read, but as Alan said he does overdo the religious stuff a bit.

Show/hide user stats
I might have seen a screening of the Touching The Void film which previews at the Kendal Film Festival and is out on general release on January 2 next year.

Unfortunately if I told you about it, I'd have to kill you all and then myself, but it might be very good.

On the book front, I'm just reading Andrew Greig's 'Kingdoms of Experience' about the Mal Duff attempt on the Everest NE ridge which like 'Summit Fever' is a pretty good antidote to the usual dull as ditchwater standard issue expedition book.
Show/hide user stats
This Game of Ghosts and The Beckoning Silence by Joe Simpson have to be among some of the most honest mountaineering books written.  The Beckoning Silence gave me serious vertigo just reading the Eiger sections!  I would also recommend Life and Limb by Jamie Andrew, very humbling and yet life affirming.
Show/hide user stats
Alex (Epic) Ford wrote (see)
There's:

"Into thin air" by Jon Krakauer.

"Regions of the heart" by Ed Douglas and some one else.

"The death zone" by Matt Dickinson.

Although these two are not "mountaineering" books they are a cracking read:

"Endurance" by Alfred Lansing - About Ernest Shackeltons epic.

"Scott's last expedition", by erm , Capt Robert Falcon Scott RN.

If you read Krakauer's diatribe, which is what it is however well written, you must balance it with the more matter of fact account of Anatoli Boukreev as related by him to G Weston DeWalt in his book "The Climb". Krakauer's account is well written and gripping but he is self serving and hypocritical in his treatment of Boukreev. He certainly doesn't emerge squeaky clean from the incident. It is clear from the testimony of expedition members other than Boukreev that he, i.e. Boukreev, was not and was not expected to be a decision maker on this expedition, a fact made abundantly clear by Scott Fischer his boss. It is quite obvious that Krakauer must have known this and although he was apparently non judgemental to Boukreev's face subjecting him to no criticism at all, he later, without any warning, lays a great deal of blame for the tragedy at Boukreev's door.

As to Krakauer's motives for this skullduggery, you'll have to judge for yourself but he did sell an awful lot of books!

Edited: 16/04/08 18:02
Show/hide user stats

H W Tilman ,seven mountain travl books and eight sailing/exploration books .And if you like them try Eric Shiptons books as well .

  But on a personal basis (i have heard of some crazy people who don't like his style ) any thing by Jim Perrin . They will charm ,delight ,and enlighten you  .

Show/hide user stats

 My top ten

Anything by HW Tilman, FS Smyth, Eric Shipton - all early  explorers of the HImalayers

Peter Mathieson - The  Snow Leopard

Houston & Bates - K2 the Savage Mountain

Julie Tullis - Clouds from both Sides

Edward Whymper - Scrambles amongst the Alps

Ralph Barker - The Last Blue Mountain 

Maurice Herzog  - The Ascent of Annapurna

Simon Calder & ??? - Boots, Bagguetes and Backpacks - for all lovers of the Pyrenees

and how can you omit the greatest achivement of all time - 

WE BOWMAN _ THE ASCENT OF RUM DOODLE  

sorry - top nine 

Show/hide user stats

Vertical Pleasure, by Mick Fowler, is a good read. Lot's of variety and Mr. F does not take himself -- or anybody else -- at all seriously, which is refreshing.

Against the Wall, by Simon Yates, is another funny look at modern climbing, drinking and being mad in South America.

Or, if you want really mad, try Alone to Everest, by Earl Denman (if you can find it). An eccentric man with little or no climbing experience who set out to do what the title of the book says, and trained for it by climbing mountains in Africa.

As Peter says, the books by F. S. Smythe are interesting -- look out for Kangchenjunga Adventure, Kamet Conquered and The Valley of Flowers. His quasi-religious views can be a bit odd, and some of his early books are very "empire", but he got a lot more open to a less European viewpoint, and the books are very evocative of an era when many mountain areas really were blanks on the map.

Show/hide user stats

Mountain Days and Bothy Nights

Hamish's Mountain Walk - Hamish Brown

Life and Limb - Jamie Andrews

The Munros and Tops - Chris Townsend

The First Fifty - Muriel Gray

Show/hide user stats

If you read Krakauer's diatribe, which is what it is however well written, you must balance it with the more matter of fact account of Anatoli Boukreev as related by him to G Weston DeWalt in his book "The Climb". Krakauer's account is well written and gripping but he is self serving and hypocritical in his treatment of Boukreev. He certainly doesn't emerge squeaky clean from the incident. It is clear from the testimony of expedition members other than Boukreev that he, i.e. Boukreev, was not and was not expected to be a decision maker on this expedition, a fact made abundantly clear by Scott Fischer his boss. It is quite obvious that Krakauer must have known this and although he was apparently non judgemental to Boukreev's face subjecting him to no criticism at all, he later, without any warning, lays a great deal of blame for the tragedy at Boukreev's door.

As to Krakauer's motives for this skullduggery, you'll have to judge for yourself but he did sell an awful lot of books!

Jugears, I agree with most of your sentiments. Have read both books and cannot help but feel that the total confusion of the circumstances at the time made for difficult balanced judgement. Boukreev was a guide and it seems did all he could and more. The responsibility lies with Fischer and Hall. The books are both compelling reading though!

Show/hide user stats
Sorry, have not worked out the previous text highligting.
Show/hide user stats
Anyone read Facing Up by the Bear Grylls bloke then? All about his going up Everest for the first time as a climber-not the later latest flight over it stunt on a big lawnmower engine, strapped to his back.
Show/hide user stats
yeah, he climbed Everest with jesus. that about sums it up.

 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
 

Page: 1  2  3  


Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > GearForum jump  
Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Article search
Support our partners

Paramo

Cotswolds

 Send to friend | Join Now ^ Top of Page
About OUTDOORSmagic
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Terms and Conditions

Subscribe to OUTDOORSMAGIC RSS news feed.
Contact Us
- Support
- Advertise with us
- FAQ
- Retailers: free site review
Affiliates
- Take our news for free
- RSS Feed
Magicalia Digital Publishing
Cycling
- BIKEmagic
- RoadCyclingUK
- SheCycles
- LondonCycleSport
- Visordown
- ProTourNews
Outdoors
- OUTDOORSmagic
- FISHINGmagic
- GOLFmagic
- TheMainSail
Lifestyle
- ThinkBaby
- Gardening.co.uk
- AVReview
- ThinkCamera
Hobbies
- ModelFlying
- MilitaryModelling
- ModelBoats
- GetWoodWorking

- Full Portfolio
© 1999-2008 Magicalia Ltd.