Thursday 11 March 2010 | Personalise | Help  
 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
Camping gas cyclinder pressures.
21 to 31 of 31 messages. Page: 1  2  To post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
 
This member’s stats are private

In short rocky your right, canisters with a propane - isobutane mix are a good way to go.

Fiona right PB mix conforms well to Raoult's Law, but in use that magic number of about 0C comes up quick in canister. What I've found is propane - butane is fine for warm weather. Propane - isobutane is good for cold weather. And for very cold weather you need tricks. (It's worth know that the ground temp can be alot lower then the air temp.)

The best of which I think is feeding the mix into the stove as a liquid (by turning the canister upside down after you have lit it(might flare - be careful)). But you need a remote stove with a preheating system.

There are lots of other tricks you can do which I sure you know and people will add....

Show/hide user stats
Oh god!     I'll use the Trangia.   You light it.  It runs out of meths.   It goes out.
Show/hide user stats
Okay, so we know that propane has a higher partial pressure than butane, because it has a lower boiling point.

Q: What does this mean about the relative evaporation rates of the two gases in the mix?

A: Propane evaporates faster.  So, as the canister is used, we end up with increasing amounts of butane.  Which means that the pressure of the canister falls, for a given temperature, as the canister is used.

We know this is true from empirical evidence; our experience of using mixed gas cylinders in the field.  The science provides the understanding, and backs up our original statements.  I tried to explain the problem without delving into partial pressures and all that malarkey; although I'm perfectly happy to deal with them, I try to provide simpler explanations that everyone can understand.

If the cylinders are kept at constant temperature, then the pressure will fall with %age capacity in the same way.  However:

i) a larger cylinder will provide more burns at a decent pressure from new, simply because its %age capacity doesn't fall as fast (for a given usage rate).  It will, though, also give more burns at a lower pressure as it reaches the lower part of its capacity.
ii) as John said, the larger cylinder has a higher thermal mass, and so will stay at a higher temperature during the burn, and will thus give marginally higher pressures than the smaller cylinder.

Another reason to carry one larger cylinder rather than two small ones is that the cylinders themselves weigh quite a bit; two 100g cylinders will weigh more than one 200g cylinder; a simple matter of surface area:volume ratios.  Even if you get to the point where the bigger cylinder is as %age empty as the two smaller cylinders, you're carrying more dead weight around.

Granted, you can't start with a new cylinder if the temperature falls...
This member’s stats are private

> Oh god!     I'll use the Trangia.   You light it.  It runs out of meths.   It goes out.

Be Careful... It more complicated then that...

This member’s stats are private
caveman john wrote (see)

 (It's worth know that the ground temp can be alot lower then the air temp.)

I ment grass temp ... oops.
Show/hide user stats
Reminded of this thread by a UKC thread, and finally got around to plotting the fall in cylinder pressure with cylinder capacity.  It's interesting, and pretty damning.

Using the vapour pressure figures provided by Fiona (probably obtained from here, which, incidentally, has mistakenly used the percentage ratios as molar percentages, when I'm pretty sure that gas is supplied as mass percentages; I've corrected for that), I determined the cylinder pressure starting with a full cylinder, and then let it be used up, using each of the two gases in proportion to the partial vapour pressure they were contributing to the mix.

http://www.outdoorsmagic.com/members/images/10187/Gallery/vapourP.jpg

Pretty dramatic loss of performance, isn't it?  By the time the cylinder is 50% empty, practically all the propane has gone, and you're burning a feeble butane pressure.

This member’s stats are private
I'm showing my age... so that's a starting temp of ~5'C then.
Show/hide user stats
Yes, it's hard work using the blasted foot-poundal per cubic gramme-banana units.  I only used those values because Fiona posted them, and I'd have much preferred to have used SI units.

40F = 4.4C  And I've assumed no change in temperature of the canister as it's used (either from evaporation, or from conductive heating from the stove).

When looking for the dHvap figures,  the first link quoted BTU/lb...

Blast: just tried another temperature and it revealed an error in the spreadsheet.  Doesn't make a huge difference:

http://www.outdoorsmagic.com/members/images/10187/Gallery/vapourP2.JPG

This member’s stats are private

> blasted foot-poundal per cubic gramme-banana units

 It's quite an a telling graph when you think about it. Could you off run a graph of for 20C with real units down the side

Show/hide user stats

Yes, 20C would be interesting.

Thanks CP, for the graph.


 You say:
Message: (1500 character limit)
(Using the Quick Post will also register you with the site)
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Email: *
Security Image:This is a security image
Write the characters shown in the image above (Case sensitive)
I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct
  
 

Page: 1  2  


Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > Hot threads > [Soapbox]Forum jump  
Support our sponsors
 
Support our sponsors
 
Travel Partners
 
Offers, Competitions and Promotions
Win Free Stuff

Win a £100 gift token
Win £100 to spend at Ultimate Adventure Hardware
Win a pair of TEVA Itunda
Revolutionizing the sports sandal with a brand new product
Win a pair of Steep GT's
Comfort, style, durability & practicality from Zamberlan
Win a Go System Fly
Get your hands on this new ultra light stove
Win 1 of 6 Walkabout Satchels
Amazing National Geographic bags worth £145 each

Advertorial: Craigdon Mountain Sports
Celebrating 25 years of Craigdon
Advertorial: Yew Clothing
You love the outdoors. You can show that by choosing Yew Clothing
Advertorial: GTC Satellite Phones
Heading into the unknown? Stay in touch with a satellite phone
Instant Expert Guide To...
Trail Running


GPS Help and User Guide