FastFind PLB

Any good?

8 messages
17/07/2012 at 23:31

Am considering one of these but have heard that due to a number of false alarms, the rescue agencies (whoever they may be) have been known to ignore the signal.  I've tried to contact the manufacturers but no answers to my questions yet.  Does anyone have any experince of them?  In my case, its first trip is to northern Norway and Sweden.

Also, once the distress signal has been pinged off, is there any way of knowing it's been received?  How long does one wait before deciding help is not on its way and one has to crawl off, Simpson-style, for a few days to get help?

Is there any reasonable alternative?  Spot doesn't seem to be without problems.

Thanks.

18/07/2012 at 06:55
I've had one for a few years....being obtuse you won't know how reliable it is till you need to..

But I did a lot of research on the options and their respective function before I bought it and it came out with good reviews. Weight was a contributory factor for me.

Edit: Quick search

http://www.equipped.org/McMurdo%20406%20MHz%20Beacons%20Test%20Report%20HiRes.pdf

http://www.equipped.org/Coast_Guard_Fastfind_Test.pdf

There is a lot more out there....I seem to recall a number of useful insights on BPL US - try a search on 'SPOT' over there?
Edited: 18/07/2012 at 07:05
18/07/2012 at 08:01

A newly published report compiled by Scottish Mountain Rescue ( part of which was published in a local paper ) said 4 incidents were initiated by P.L.B's in Scotland,

In Scotland 19% of accidents were caused by people slipping and 14% by navigational errors, 157 casualties were evacuated by helicopter with 71 being walked off the hill by teams and 65 being stretchered off the hill.

18/07/2012 at 11:33

I'd be interested if anyone's had practical experience of using Spot in Norway/Sweden: the maps tend to give the idea of limited satellite coverage in the Northern areas, but practical experience counts for more than maps! PLBs would seem more reliable (in terms of emergency use) but don't give the ability to send "I'm OK and at location X" signals, which seem very handy for a lone walker.

18/07/2012 at 12:26
Chris, OutdoorsGrub.co.uk wrote (see)

but don't give the ability to send "I'm OK and at location X" signals


Some do - like the ACR 406.
22/07/2012 at 22:05
Sorry, just catching upon emails etc.  Thanks all.  Hadn't heard of the 406, I wonder, ed, if you know anything about it?
22/07/2012 at 22:18
Sorry Rob, just read a few Press Reports - not looked for a review or anything.
24/07/2012 at 16:29

Not sure about the coverage of spot in the the far north but I have a spot 2 and it has never let me down (only used it for OK messages so far mind) 

Like any communications syatem it has to be used sensibly.  it only tries to get a GPS lock once the button has been pressed so try to do that when you stop for a break as moving slows things down.

I use it as I mainly walk solo and my missus was starting to get a bit nervous when I am out of contact for too long.  I also take it out on the boat (a RIB) as I only have a handheld VHF radio with limited range.

I had a mark 1 prior and that one was fine too, maybe a little slower getting a lock and a signal out.

Steve D

Your say
email image
8 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Competitions

Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions