New Synthetic Insulated Jacket

1 to 20 of 24 messages
02/02/2011 at 19:21
Hi, I am wanting to replace my old Rab Generator Smock. Ideally I want a jacket with hood and a couple of pockets, I need it to fit over all my other layers. I was looking at the Rab Generator Alpine and Montane Flux and Maybe Rab Photon. Does anyone have these jackets and could give me a rundown of pros and cons of ie, fit, features , warmth, packability. I want it to be reasonably lightweight also no more than 600g if possible. Cheers
02/02/2011 at 20:03

Richard

give a thought for the Patagonia Micropuff hoody. Hood, pockets ,and comes up big to go over everything.

02/02/2011 at 21:03
Also give the Montane Prism jacket a look.  Its less weight than the Flux so not as warm but you can layer a fleece underneath to increase the insulation.  Full details on the Montane website.  I picked one up in the January sales for £60.00.
03/02/2011 at 01:03

I recently bought a Patagonia Micro Puff Hoody (half-price at The Epicentre), but ended up selling it on as it as not as good as the new Rab Photon Jacket imo:

The Rab has 133g/m2 Primaloft in the body rather than 100.

It has a larger hood which is also far more adjustable than the Micro Puff's.

And the real decider - for some strange reason Patagonia has stitched the Primaloft to the outer fabric of the jacket rather than the liner, creating hundreds of stitch holes to let water through far quicker than it otherwise would.

I'd also pick the Rab over the Montanes just on the basis that they are only 40g/m2 or 60g/m2 fill, designed more for wearing whilst on the move rather than throwing on for stops/belays.

Edited: 03/02/2011 at 01:16
03/02/2011 at 07:04

Richard,

How about the Sigma smock from PHD?  IME their DriShell is more wether resistant than either ME's DriLoft or RAB's Pertex Endurance (the way it has been stitched means there are minimal needle holes on the outer too),  the front pocket is huge and has a zippered inner pocket too, removable hood and very light.  I've used mine under a shell and over base layer to -15'C and below.

For sizes I usually find PHD slightly smaller than other sizes but you can ring these guys up, speak to the boss direct and they can tinker with sizes to get the right fit ect.  The only possible downside is the time taken to make it - expect 4 weks from order to delivery, but it is worth it.

James

03/02/2011 at 10:21

I think the Montane Flux is a very good jacket. It weighs 575gm on not very accurate kitchen scales. Packs down into a 4L Alpkit stuffsac or a small OD sac.

However I find it very warm for active use unless the temperature is very low and/or you are exposed to harsh wind chill - when it is a great piece of kit.

03/02/2011 at 10:59
Thanks to everyone for your advice, I am looking at some deals, the Montane Flux for £85 at the Climbers Shop and the Rab Generator Alpine at Outside for £99. I tried on a Montane Prism a few weeks ago and found that I had to go up to XL size I wonder if the fit of the Flux will be similar? I need for the Jacket to go over  layers as a belay type jacket, I am usually a large size in Rab Clothing, does anyone know what the fit of the Generator alpine is like? Also tentatively eyeing up the Mountain Equipment Fitzroy, but its Pricey. The patagonia deals are tempting too  but Im not sure they will fit the bill.
03/02/2011 at 12:27
Richard - I've got a Fitzroy, bought on a whim, and really, surplus to requirements. That is, either it or the Flux have to go. If you're interested in a pretty much brand new, worn only to walk the dog, ME Fitzroy, in large, £100 (inclusive of recorded delivery, mainland UK), let me know.
03/02/2011 at 12:37
Richard, the fit of the Alpine Generator is exactly the same as the Photon Jacket and the Generator Jacket/Pullover.  If you can get your Generator Smock over your other layers, then stick with the same size for the Alpine Generator (although, of course, it is far easier to put on than wrestling with an over-the-head garment).
03/02/2011 at 12:52

Another option is the Haglofs barrier hood. I've got the barrier jacket and its superb imho. Here is a link to browse if your interested.

http://www.haglofs.com/en-US/products/clothing/layers/insulation/men/barrier_hood_en-us.aspx

03/02/2011 at 18:06

Blacks are knocking out the Berghaus Ignite Hoody at £75.  100g PL1 in body, 60g in sleeves & hood.  I got mine in Basingstoke, where they still had quite a few left.  If you're XXL and can cope with blue/white, it's online.

It's a nicely cut jacket, with a hood that fits over a helmet* (Petzl Elios), but still fits over the head nicely.  It doesn't have the silly moulded plastic cuff adjusters, just good, old skool fabric flaps.

* I think... unless I'm geting confused with the monster Infinity...

03/02/2011 at 18:52
I really like my Haglofs Barrier vest and quite regret going for the full jacket. It's got a great fully-zipped up feel, no chin-chafing etc. Cheaper than Rab too, and what was a big selling point for me, it wasn't as shiny.
06/02/2011 at 10:29
Still considering the Montane Flux but seen a few comments that the sleeves are quite close fitting and so it is not ideal to put on over the top of thick layers, can anyone shed more light on this?
06/02/2011 at 12:19

Ok, and Im not taking the P##s I think the Bear grylls clima hoody is fantastic and for £50 very good value for money. I dont know what the specs are for it but at the same time I bought a patagonia ( heavier one than the Nano) and actually prefer the bear jacket.

Have a look you may be surprised

07/02/2011 at 17:28

> with a hood that fits over a helmet* (Petzl Elios)

Checked: BH Ignite Hoody hood does fit over helmet.  Reviews on BH site are fair: pockets could do with being a little higher to clear harness/pack strap, it could do with a bigger internal pocket to take a water bottle.

07/02/2011 at 21:14

The Flux is a good jacket, I used it in the Lakes last week as soft shell and the hood was very welcome but, it sbaout as warm as 300wt fleece

08/02/2011 at 16:00

I have a Flux and its a great fit. I found the ME and Rab too short in the arm for my size.

 I'm 6'3" and 42 chest. I got bought an XL flux on internet so was nervous about size but i had spoke to Montane Technical support first and they designed the jacket sizes to be worn over kit as a belay jacket should be.

Once it arrived i wore a base layer, a 100 fleece and TNF Mountain Guide jacket (XL). I then got the flux on top of all that. Had no problem moving arms. It was a close fit but not tight and this would keep you warm whilst belaying. The arms are also long. I have arms that are long, hence this is important, so it was great to have a jacket were the arms are well below my wrists.

The jacket itself is very warm. Have not used it belaying neither has it been wet but i have every confidence in it. The tech support people know what they are talking about and understand what people want and why. They have included this in the design spec.

It packs down into its own pocket. The pockets are huge though but i agree with what the guy says above, without trying a stuff sac myself. The pockets are great when on. Two huge chest and two huge hand warmers. All above harness, so accessable all the time.

I also got it from backcountry.com. If you know anybody in the US? It was half price £63.

08/02/2011 at 16:16
Thanks for the info Trevor, I had my eye on a bargain Flux but the last ones gone damn it! Another option I am looking at is to get a Montane Prism ( a bit cheaper) and using it in conjunction with my PHD Minimus Drishell vest.
08/02/2011 at 16:21
Richard W wrote (see)
I need for the Jacket to go over  layers as a belay type jacket, I am usually a large size in Rab Clothing, does anyone know what the fit of the Generator alpine is like?
I finally had a look at a Generator Alpine today. I'm a long time Generator Smock user and really noticed the extra thickness/warmth of the material. I am an XL smock user and I put the Alpine in XL on over my Paramo jacket which had a light fleece under. The sleeve length was very good (for me as a long armed chap) and it had room to overlay nicely. 'I want one' is all I can add.
08/02/2011 at 17:40
Have you tried wildtrak.com?? Or google shopping and you get some good results. Thats how i got mine for so cheap a price.
1 to 20 of 24 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions