Last September, I returned a pair of Inov8 shoes to Fitness Footwear. I sent the package 2nd class and some weeks later noticed that I had not received a refund. On contacting Fitness Footwear, they maintained that they had no record of receiving the package and that I had to pursue a claim for compensation from the Royal Mail.
I duly filled out a detailed form and sent it to Royal Mail Customer Services, enclosing proof of posting and proof of value (both originals as required). The form promised a response within 30 days. Over 2 months passed and I heard nothing. Earlier this month, I sent a letter by recorded delivery, requesting an update on my claim. A few days later I got a letter back stating that "A significant increase in recent customer enquiries has meant it is taking longer than we would like to respond to customers." Presumably this was management speak for "With lots of pre-Christmas post, our staff are losing / stealing far more of it than usual."
This morning I got a cheque for £43.84, being £41 compensation and the balance being the cost of the postage. Second class postage only covers compensation up to £41.
So, next time you are returning a bit of kit to a supplier, it may be worth paying the extra insurance. I have always objected to this as it smacks of extortion. I am paying the postage fee as consideration for the Royal Mail to deliver my package. Why should I pay extra to cover the incompetence of their staff? If I book a taxi, I don't expect the option of paying an extra fee to insure myself against being robbed by the driver.
This time, I only lost £31 but if the item had been, say, a £250 sleeping bag, I would have been well out of pocket.