Sleeping Bag Advice.

15 messages
27/04/2010 at 16:31
After all your good advice to another forumite I thought I'd post my query.

I am looking for Bag for my wife and another for myself, with 2 slightly different specs!

For the other half, I need a bag which will keep her warm at altitudes of up to 5000m, in a tent whilst, on trekking holidays in the Andes or Himalayas. She will not be carrying it so weight isn't a massive issue other than the obvious 15kg for everything that the porters/sherpas/yak etc will take. She sleeps cold.

For myself my bag must do all the above but I will on occasion be carrying it, mostly between huts/bivvies both in the UK and the Alps, so weight and pack size are more of an issue. Also I can't stand liners as I'm a fidgeter!

Also in both cases build quality and ethical down are pretty important, and whilst I don't which to sell a kidney I am prepared to pay for quality.

I have done a fair bit of research and have a few front runners in mind, however I will keep my ideas to myself to avoid queering the pitch.

Thanks in advance guys.
28/04/2010 at 12:44
bump
28/04/2010 at 19:54
Hi- I've opted for a Rab Quantum 800 Endurance for an upcoming trip to the Andes which I managed to get hold of from a US website for £200, but I've got a friend bringing it over for me...

They are now discontinued (they were about £320), but can be found reduced in places like Needle Sports in Keswick (check out their website) for £265. This is for a bag conservatively rated to -23c, with a waterproof(ish) fabric, that weighs in at a very reasonable 1382g.Pack size is 21x35cm. Sounds like it will be right up both of your streets!
29/04/2010 at 18:23

Thanks, was looking at Rabs new an old range.

Wh

ere and when you going?

29/04/2010 at 18:42
I've got four weeks personal climbing in Bolivia coming up (might do some touristy (jungle/salt plains etc)and then I'm leading a youth expedition in the Peruvian Andes for four weeks- heading over to Machu Picchu via the alternative route, trekking in the Colca Canyon, exploring Lake Titicaca, and some project work in Cusco. Heading out there 12th June. How about yourself?
29/04/2010 at 18:48
PS I have a Rab Summit 300 which is about 750g, and is rated to -2/0c, however, I've used it down towards -15c in Scottish winters (ok- I was very cold!!) and in the French Alps above 3500m in the summer, and its been a great buy- it has a hugely useful temperature arrange, apart from when it gets super-baltic.
29/04/2010 at 19:07

Hi Chris,

It was nice to meet you at the Om winter course.

Heres my two pence worth.

I have only being using down sleeping bags for just over a year but have been using crappy syntetic bags for twenty so I know what its like to be cold at night, but not anymore

All last year I slept in a Alpkit PD400 and it did the trick, for the OM snowholing course I used it with a Regular Neo Air, event Bivi bag and down trousers and jacket and I was toasty.  The outside temp that night was -15 and it was not much warmer in the show hole.  If it was going to be any colder than that I would have been packing a down mat and PHD Hispar 800 (1240g)

You mention you would like a bag you can carry yourself, it might be worth looking at the Alpkit PD800 for herself and get a PHD bag for yourself.

Cheers,

Stephen

30/04/2010 at 07:25

Cheers Guys, you're suggestions align with the ideas I've been kicking around.

Tom, sounds great we did the tourist Inca trail a couple years ago as part of a tour of Peru.  Feels strange to be with only the trekkers for a couple of days then surrounded by tourist when you get to Machu Picchu.

As for your Jungle trip I can heartily recommend trying to get up to the Tambopata Research Centre the journey upriver is stunning and the clay lick near the centre is a must do!

edit: We're doing the Huayhuash circuit in Jun/July

Edited: 30/04/2010 at 15:00
02/05/2010 at 20:59
Cheers for the info Chris. I spent four weeks river-leading and sleeping rough on the Amazon last year, but my girlfriend who will be with me wants to see the rainforest this summer, so I think we'll be taking a trip into the Maddi Reserve in Bolivia. On the actual expedition I'm leading, we'll be avoiding the Inca Trail and doing an independent trek into MP on the Salkantay route from Mollepata.

On another note, I really wanted to do the Huayhuash Circuit too- are you doing it on your own or with a group? I had persuaded my missus to do it last two weeks in June, but we tentatively decided on a full four weeks in Bolivia instead. Have you got the John Biggar guide to trekking in the Andes? I met him a month or two ago and he has loads of info- he's happy for people to contact him for free advice, and is a very nice chap...

his website:

http://www.andes.org.uk/



03/05/2010 at 00:10

We're going with Exodus, My wife is a "Lite Camper" only so organised groups are the way forward!  Also I quite like meeting and socialising with other group members.  I will defo have a look at the website thanks, as I like to have a good idea of where I am and how the geography lines up so to speak.

If you ever go over and do a river lead again and need a bag lacky I'm your man (pretty handy in boats aswell!)

On the subject of Bags I am coming down on the side of the PhD Hispar 400 or 500 for myself and the New Rab Ascent 700W for my wife. The only thing is I'd like something a little warmer for her but there's nothing in Ladies bag ranges around -10 seemingly from anyone. It was suggested that I look at an Atlas 750W and get a bit more down put in but I wonder if that would just be too much down for the baffle size.

03/05/2010 at 03:13

I have read post on the US BPL site about how its possible to overstuff down by something like 1.5 times the 'optimum' loft level before losing significant efficiency. As I understand it, this means that if you take a standard bag and stuff in 50% extra down then it will be almost 1.5 times as warm, even though the down cannot loft to the full extent. This is somewhat counter intuitive as its generally thought the trapped air rather than the down  that does the insulating. In fact CP from this site queried the original poster and received a somewhat prickly response. Overall I get the impression that people with overstuffed bags are generally happy with the result, given the following qualifiers - the bags are only overstuffed by maybe 10-20% and I doubt many of the people with overstuffed bags have done a direct comparison with the standard fill level.

Sorry for rambling on a bit but its an interesting subject for me - I probably should get out more...

I like montbell bags as the company, despite covering almost every aspect of outdoor gear, seem to have a great deal of expertise in down wear. Their bags offer some of the best 'official temp rating' to 'official weight' ratios inthe industry, though maybe not quite up to PHD levels, at reasonable prices i.e. they are not cheap but once again not in PHD territory. Why montbell dont have a UK presence is a mystery to me. Having said that, they are about as far from a local cottage industry company as you can get, but then again so is the likes of Rab, Montane these days.

12/05/2010 at 11:29
Just curious to know wether anyone has seen the Rab Andes 800 for less than 360 notes?  Perversely cotswold sell the Andes 1000 for 400 quid but I can get a 15% discount, however i reckon that the 1000 will be too warm most of the time! and it's another 240g ish.
12/05/2010 at 12:29
12/05/2010 at 12:47
Thank you, feel free to claim your beer if we're ever in the same place!
12/05/2010 at 14:07

 I'll hold you to that

Your say
email image
15 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions