Tent suggestions

9 messages
20/05/2012 at 10:13
My current tent (North Face Aguila33) is pretty good - sensible weight, lots of space, but erection is a bit of a chore, and the slope on the doors means that opening isn't pleasant when raining.

I like my space and comfort, so a tiny tent is out. I am not into anything extreme - mainly safe campsites.

As I say, I like my comfort, so we use large exped synmats. They are 65*200 ish.

So, I need a space that has minimums of about 140*210, I want sensible weight and easy pitching - preferably outer first or both together.

First research suggests the Vaude Terratrio 3P is close to what I am looking for, but I have no idea on ease of pitching. Other suggestions welcome.

Thanks,
Paul.
20/05/2012 at 11:56

We had very similar wants to yours and ended up with a Hilleberg Kaitum 3.  You can take your pick between the 2 or 3.  The 2 will do all you want, the 3 adds enough space for another person, taking you from lots of space to absolutely loads of the stuff, for not that much extra weight and bulk.

There's a good porch at either end and sitting height through the whole inner so each occupant can stay out of the other's way if they want.  Being a Hillie it's a doddle to pitch and goes up all in one.  You can take the inner out or roll it back for extra choices if you want.

Main catch is significant cost, but I've never regretted ours and I'd replace like for like if it went.  It's significantly more than the VauDe mentioned and a little heavier, but you get a lot more space that can be used more flexibly thanks to twin entrances.

Pete.

20/05/2012 at 13:58
In my opinion, Hillies whilst expensive are worth every penny.
They are very quick and easy to put up. If the other space/shape/layout are right for you then I would say find the funds and buy a Hillie.
20/05/2012 at 20:29
Mountain Equipment Dragonfly 2XT?

May have one sale if you're interested?
20/05/2012 at 20:39
I had noticed how close they match my requirements - I was looking primarily at the Nallo 3 but the price was discouraging. I doubt the budget will stretch to one this year.

The Kaitum 2 does look strikingly close to my stated requirements, doesn't it!

The dragonfly looks a little narrow for the two mats I need. Now, where to find someone neot too far where I can see one. Bolton area - manchester/preston.Liverpool. I think I'd rather look at the non-gt variants.

I think I may need to start saving up...

Thanks so far, further suggestions appreciated.

Paul.
20/05/2012 at 23:18

Hillebergs have a very high reputation and also a very high price to match. For the price of a Hilleberg you could have just about any tent on the market, or 2 or 3 good quality cheaper tents.

I'm not sure whether you need to spend that much money.

Are you intending to backpack your tent? What sort of weight is reasonable for you?

High prices get you exotic materials, which basically means a higher strength to weight ratio.

The Vaude design has the poles clipped on the outside. So you should be able to pitch it quite quickly but it probably won't have the highest stability. Tents where the poles attach to the inner, or are fed through sleeves, will probably take longer to pitch but may be more stable.

Tunnel tents are quicker to pitch than geodetics as you don't have so many poles. However they are more likely to flap in the wind and may have to be pitched more carefully. The Lightwave web site gives a summary of the pros and cons of tunnel and geodetic tents:

http://www.lightwave.uk.com/en/tents_tunneltents.php

http://www.lightwave.uk.com/en/tents_geodesictents.php

Although the concept of pitching outer first or all in one is preferable in a rainy climate it is not that big a deal. So I wouldn't rule out a tent that is otherwise suitable merely because it pitches inner first.

If you want other economical choices you could have a browse of the Vango website. Then try google or ebay for the cheapest price. There are so many possibilities it is hard to give you specific advice.

There are also less conventional possibilities like a Shangri La 3, if you can find one still available in this country.

There are various videos on ebay of tents being pitched (Kaitum versus a typical dome tent).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMmko823KBE

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K4QpkRCUBJw

20/05/2012 at 23:26
A Hillie tent that is only used for trekking (so each day in and out the backpack, in in the morning and out at the end of the day) stays good for at least 15 to 20 years (oke you might have to replace the groundsheet of the inner if you don't use an extra footprint sheet). My Hilli Niak has already passed the 15 years and is still in very good condition.
21/05/2012 at 07:27
Have they just updated the Lightwave web site?

I am sure when I looked a couple of weeks ago there were no floorplans.

There's still a couple of dimensions I'd like to see missing - the width of the bottom end, and how long that taper is, but a T30 looks interesting.

For weight I'd like to go as light as practical, but below 3K is acceptable.

Paul.
21/05/2012 at 11:24

Hillebergs have a very high reputation and also a very high price to match. For the price of a Hilleberg you could have just about any tent on the market, or 2 or 3 good quality cheaper tents.

You could, but of course you can only use one at once...

I'm not sure whether you need to spend that much money.

You pretty much categorically don't need to, but that doesn't mean you'll regret it if you do.

Are you intending to backpack your tent?

Or otherwise move it around the wild?  I must admit I'd only get a Hillie purely for formal campgrounds if I'd just won the lottery.

The Vaude design has the poles clipped on the outside. So you should be able to pitch it quite quickly but it probably won't have the highest stability. Tents where the poles attach to the inner, or are fed through sleeves, will probably take longer to pitch but may be more stable.

Though one needs to draw a distinction between stability in terms of small movements and stability in terms of falling down.  External clips may affect the former but not significantly the latter, assuming the design's done properly (and I think VauDe know what they're at).

Tunnel tents are quicker to pitch than geodetics as you don't have so many poles.

If all else is equal, but all else may not be.  I'd be very surprised if I could pitch a 3 pole Lightwave t2xt as fast as my 4 pole Tarra, for example.

Although the concept of pitching outer first or all in one is preferable in a rainy climate it is not that big a deal. So I wouldn't rule out a tent that is otherwise suitable merely because it pitches inner first.

I'd agree it's not a deal breaker, but there's more to it than just keeping the inner dry pitching.  For me, a far more useful point is the ability to take down part or all of the inner and get extra space to invite your pals over for tea without getting everything mucky, or have undercover garage space to work on a bike or unload a boat, sort out wet gear etc.  You can't do that if the inner has to stand up for your tent to be in place.  Lots of people do without that, but I suspect a case of not missing what you don't have.

Now, where to find someone neot too far where I can see one. Bolton area - manchester/preston.Liverpool.

Drop Alpenstock (Stockport) a line.  They're a main Hillie dealer and also have (or at least had) as good a price as you'll find.

Pete.

Your say
email image
9 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions