Waterproof Stuff sacks

Do they exist?

1 to 20 of 22 messages
27/05/2012 at 17:24

Going trekking for 5 weeks this summer and this week I am starting to plan my system for packing. I have decided what I want to do is to organise everything into stuffsacks and then put everything inside a large, 30-50 ltr drybag. I'm only taking 2 and a half sets of clothes, so whilst I will obviously be wearing one set the other will be in my bag- so for safety reasons (it can be quite cold where I'm going) I want to have a back up system in case the drybag fail, as if my pack is wet the likelyhood is so am I - Hence the need for waterproof stuff sacks. 

A quick google search comes out with nothing. 

Thanks

27/05/2012 at 17:27
Alternatively do I buy a ripstop nylon waterproof and then cut it up, and DIY?
27/05/2012 at 17:33

Very much so and in numerous types - a good cross section here.

The only ones which count as really waterproof are small drybags of course, as the hole is a hindrance otherwise

Slightly oddly perhaps the podsac website at least does seem to imply that they seam seal their stuff sacs. Other people perhaps do?!

27/05/2012 at 17:34
Lots of companies do em -- Exped, Sea tro Summit and Alpkit, to name but three.
27/05/2012 at 17:36
Sports Direct/Field and Trek do a range of Karrimor ones that goes from XXS (5 litres) to XL (40+ Litres) most of the larger Sports Direct shops have them in stock so you can have a look before you buy.
27/05/2012 at 17:39
I have seen sleeping bag bags with a small piece fabric like a giant label on the inside of the bag that you can slide over the top of the things inside. I suppose even if they were showerproof they would offer reasonable assurance. Perhaps even i could use drybags, but wasnt sure how the liner drybag would stand up to 5 weeks of abrasion from the clips ect, at least with stuffsacks there is very little plastic on them.
27/05/2012 at 17:58
The Karrimor Dry bags are the traditional design for such products with taped seams.  This means they have "roleover tops" that are then secured by a fastex buckle so they are waterproof at the closure point.
27/05/2012 at 18:40
I have a few drybags already, alpkit and sea to summit, which I tend to use for my sleeping bag. I think my main concern was is it alright to put drybags within drybags or will the abrasion create holes- hence why I was looking for stuffsacks made from a waterproof material as the clip is much smaller and rounder.
27/05/2012 at 19:04

Abrasion... up to  apoint, with sufficiently heavy use after a while, but I'd say a bit of a non-issue TBH.  Use something like Ortliebs which are bomber enough (even their lighter ones) and it's even less of a worry.

But if you think about it, if a dry-bag is going to ruin your bigger dry-bag you'd better leave out anything with zips and buttons etc...

Pete.

27/05/2012 at 19:38

Seriously I wouldnt worry about dry bags inside dry bags, its overly conservative IMO. Even if your dry bag does develop a hole you could patch it with duct tape (which is generally a good thing to have in your pack anyway) If you put wet clothes in your dry bag just carry a polythene bag to stop them getting everything else wet.

Alex

28/05/2012 at 10:11

I have been using mutliple dry bags to waterproof kit for years and never had a problem, this has also kept my kit dry in all weathers, terrain (including the jungle) and also during several river crossings.

"Seriously I wouldnt worry about dry bags inside dry bags, its overly conservative IMO. Even if your dry bag does develop a hole you could patch it with duct tape (which is generally a good thing to have in your pack anyway) If you put wet clothes in your dry bag just carry a polythene bag to stop them getting everything else wet.

Alex "

This approach maybe fine for day hikes were dry clothes/sleeping bag aren't critical but on a mutli day hike i would say having your kit waterproofed properly not only improves your comfort levels but in certain situations can be a life saver.

28/05/2012 at 11:02
Decathlon do a series of drybags which seal with velcro and do not have the rigid plastic type of seal which could abrade things.
What sort of water entry are you trying to prevent? If its less than total immersion,or bladder bursting, a bin bag liner to the rucsac and other stuff in the supermarket reuseable carriers[5p at ASDA] is perfectly adequate in most conditions. Be a pain in buying such bags and give them a once over. I've found that their water retention is pretty good, just a small drip, and so should be OK. by. Put your down sleeping bag in wproof bag but otherwise??
28/05/2012 at 11:07

I'd not go for binliners 'cause IME they rip too easily.  A rubble sack, OTOH, is cheap, easily available and generally tough enough to remain intact when needed.

As for the critical life-saver of a dry bag, the bag will be in the inside dey-bag without the hole, so it's still nae bother.

Pete.

28/05/2012 at 11:59
Because we are going to be too far away from a source to replace kit I have adopted a worse case scenario approach to everything. Here are a couple of possible situations that I have thought of and therefore why I think I need a double layer of protection- perhaps not though

1. If the rucksack liner breaks on day one do I have a back up- if everything is in another drybag then yes.

2. we are a ten man team with either 3 or 4 3 man tents. If 3 then they will sometimes be no room for kit- left outside. Worst case scenario, storm rolls in. Need to be confident kit is waterproof.

3. river crossing. Wearing one set of clothes other in bag. If bag gets wet the likelihood is so am I, cold weather day, I get cold, -dangerous?

Im probably going to buy these as they look light enough yet I have faith in alpkit that they will be durable enough to act as a backup. http://www.alpkit.com/shop/cart.php?target=product&product_id=16316&category_id=295 Anyone got any experience with these.
Edited: 28/05/2012 at 12:02
28/05/2012 at 12:04
Those Alpkit drybags are the ones I use. I've used them for about 30 nights I guess (14 of which came on a 2 week trip around Iceland) They havent shown any signs of wear yet. I also carted about 15kg of water around in one of them to save some tadpoles this weekend! It held up perfectly
28/05/2012 at 12:26

Because we are going to be too far away from a source to replace kit I have adopted a worse case scenario approach to everything

Well, up to a point...  There's actual worst case and reasonably likely worst case.  The first is impossible to deal with and the second must account for a bit of leeway.

If you've got 10 folk you are most unlikely to destroy 10 dry bags, so you don't need 10 spares.  1 or 2 might be smart, but if every individual takes multiply redundant gear for everthing the worst case is you won't be able to move! The more folk you have the more slack you can have in the system.  You're cold and your spare jumper is wet?  One of your nine pals might be able to lend you one for a while...

Pete.

28/05/2012 at 15:37

Alpkit Airlocks are the cheapest dry bags i've seen so far...I'm not doubting their quality either...I trust Alpkit stuff

Ed

28/05/2012 at 20:35

I agree with AN - dry bags in dry bag is overkill IMO and it's surprising how these little things add weight.  I have used an Exped 40 litre dry bag as a rucsac liner for several years - it's fine.  I don't know what you'd do to wreck it!

My sleeping bag and duvet go in their own stuff sacs, which are at least water repellant.  Only things I really want to keep dry go in this bag.  I sometimes carry a 13 litre dry bag or stuff sac to keep near the top of my sac, so I can put a fleece in it if I have to shed a layer.  Same bag can be used inside out to contain my waterproofs if wet, as a pillow (if I am wearing my spare clthes for warmth).  I have not had a problem with this system yet... 

I suppose you could use stuffs sac made of waterproof material (Alkit are good). Guess you need to consider just how serious getting stuff damp is.  Life threatening?  And if there's so many of you, surely you can help each other out?  Where are you going (if you dont mind my asking?)?

28/05/2012 at 21:10
Rob that is what I thought initially, hence why I posted "waterproof stuff sacks"- perhaps I should have asked if people know of stuff sacks made of a waterproof material instead. I am going to Northern Norway. I have come to the conclusion that I'm going to buy 4-5 stuffsacks with a really durable rucksack liner- like a proper kayaking one. I have heard good things about ortlieb and they look like what I'm after but am yet to get my hands on one so we shall wait and see.
28/05/2012 at 21:23
Calum - have spent two 3 1/2 week spells there recently, including Sarek, so I can vouch for the value of these bags in that location.  We reckon the first 3 weeks in Sept are best - mozzie free(ish), still long days, Northern Lights, low rivers, very good weather.  When are you going?
1 to 20 of 22 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions