> A recipe for a dull and anodyne forum IMO
No need for it to be dull or anodyne. You just need to be a bit more imaginitive.
If you met me, you'd know that I swear like a trooper. However, like most people, I moderate that language when I know that there are people around who might take offence. And, in an open-access, public forum, there may well be people who will take offence. And, given that I don't like to give offence, I will moderate my language.
I also don't see the point in trolling, flame wars, or starting fights. There's enough grief in the world without deliberately going around causing aggravation for fun.
The Windy thread has a long history, and Jon has, I think, taken the attitude that it's the forum's 'anything goes' thread. But I'd prefer to see the language in it not creep out into the rest of the forum. Yes; you and I might be big boys who aren't bothered by a few words, but not everyone on the forum will be.
It's really about consideration for others.
And, as Kate has pointed out, OM does have a code of conduct that isn't much different from the walkingforum.