Wind Turbines

What do you think of wind turbines?

1 to 20 of 36 messages
30/06/2003 at 12:01
In the part of Wales where I live wind turbines are popping up like mushrooms. They are dividing communities as opinions are very polarized, you either luv em or hate em.
What are your thoughts?
There are, as always, pros and cons but
overall I think they are OK. Certainly preferable than more green house gasses or nuclear but..........
30/06/2003 at 12:18
I like them.
At work so no time to go into the reasons...
30/06/2003 at 12:22
There is a certain NIMBY ring to the complaints about Wind Turbines. In California the hills are covered with hundreds of them, and generally people welcome them.

I suspect that the same sort of things were said about windmills when they first appeared
30/06/2003 at 12:43
I like them and would happily have them on my hill (ok, its not technically MY hill but you know what I mean)

Renewable power sources should be encouraged at every oppertunity for obvious reasons.

Possibly the best news is the huge investment in offshore wind turbines which are bigger more efficient and have no real opposition from the local community, fish are so open minded.
30/06/2003 at 13:15
Renewable power supply should of course be encouraged at every possible opportunity, but as I understand it the licenses that have been granted for these wind farms fall far short of the mark.

I am led to believe that in the rush to be seen to be backing the goverment's requirement to produce a certain percentage of the UK's energy production from renewable sources, corners have been cut left right and centre. For example, in a number of the installations (and I am pretty sure this doesn't apply to all of them) there is no inclusion of whose reponsibility it is to maintain the site, or remove old turbines. The result is that already you quite often see decommisioned, rusting towers that the councils can't afford to remove, and that the power companies have abandoned.

With regards the offshore wind farms, the word is that by the time they are actually commissioned, the technology will be so far out of date that they will be uneconomic to run for more than about a year!

Southampton and Cowes are currently a world centre for wind turbine production (we regularly see ships laden with the carbon blades being driven out of the Solent, showing that the UK can be involved on a global scale, but there needs to be a lot more practical thought about the consequences before we rush in like fools because Tony wants to win another term.

Other than that, I really like them, and think that their majesty really graces a number of the locations that they have been put in.
30/06/2003 at 13:51
My information from the project mamagement companies and scheme promotors is that a large proportion of the north sea offshore turbines are due for completion by the end of 2004. Obviously these will be delayed, most engineering / construction projects are, but still thats not too far into the future.
30/06/2003 at 14:09
wonderful, they add a certain majesty to the view - fascinating to watch as well (i'm easily amused) - DW gets it right with windmills
30/06/2003 at 14:12
I think that the problem is that these offshore installations have taken so long to push through the bureaucracy and finally get started that they are building to technology that is already dated.

I don't have the specific information here with me, but will ask the misses to dig it out; she has been working for the environmental department at Hampshire CC for a few years, and was my source.
30/06/2003 at 15:04
I reckon wind farms are strangely beautiful. I'm not saying I'd want a turbine next to my house, but I have no aesthetic or visual quarrel with them at all.

OutdoorsMagic Editor | jon@outdoorsmagic.com 

30/06/2003 at 15:36
No problems at all.
30/06/2003 at 16:05
Wind farms are a good idea, offshore wind farms are a great idea (more work for me).

I used to work in renewables and the government attitude at that time was terrible. I still feel they are going about it in the wrong way. Renewables are not going to supply big cities, they just can't cope with power surges. What they should be used for is island communites (Islay) and isolated places (Glen Affric YH). Small scale projects where the energy produced goes direct to the user and not lost in the national grid.
30/06/2003 at 16:09
I've nothing against them but I don't live next door to any wind farms.

I think they look a bit strange but aren't unpleasant to look at, at least not in the way that some butt-ugly housing developments are unpleasant.

In fact I think they have a certain graceful charm and wouldn't mind a few near me. There has to be some use for those ****ing cold winds from off the north sea that make the fen country so cold in winter.
30/06/2003 at 16:48
If I ever manage to build my own house, it'll be a self-sustaining eco-friendly house (I would have said "green", but that'd've been an easy target), so I'd have no problems using a turbine to contribute to the power (along with solar energy, and geothermal for heating).

It's about time we started to look seriously at alternative, renewable energy, as opposed to these half-arsed efforts which seem to have taken place over the years. The government are starting to take a better stance on the matter (I think you can still apply for a grant if you want to convert to solar energy, for example), so the sooner we start implementing more eco-friendly systems, the better :)

That goes for cars too :)
30/06/2003 at 18:01
Some people who live close to the turbines complain of the noise, never been that close myself. Even the offshore scheme proposed for Cardigan Bay has come up against opposition, because opponents say they may interfere with the bottle nose dolphins communication methods.
I think they are gracefull to, but I have little niggles about a turbine farm of 50 350' turbines on the Cambrian range. Having said that I am consuming electricity at this precise moment. I like Pauls eco-friendly house idea. Have you ever visited CAT (centre for alternative technology near Machynleth? It's worth a visit if in the area.
30/06/2003 at 19:45
Cheers for that post Lewis. Mrs F and I were talking about it only the other day and neither of us could remember either the name of the place OR where it was! We shall have to arrange a visit.
01/07/2003 at 00:16
Alex - tell your kids' school what a splendid place it would be for a trip and then go along as a parent helper....
01/07/2003 at 09:18
http://www.cat.org.uk if that's any help? I'm thinking of joining, to get the subscription to their "Clean Slate" magazine.

Thanks Lewis - it's been a dream of mine for some years now, but I refuse to get a mortgage, so it could take a little saving! I'm saving quite a bit at the moment for various things, so one day I'll get my eco-house. It should be cheaper than buying a house anyway, since I'll design it, sort out materials etc, and choose the contractors.
01/07/2003 at 09:19
PS - if anyone wants to lend a helping hand building it...if/when I get there!
01/07/2003 at 11:21
Cheers for the link Hodge.
02/07/2003 at 10:19
There's also the Earth Centre in Doncaster - http://www.earthcentre.org.uk
1 to 20 of 36 messages
Forum Jump  
Sign up to our weekly newsletter
Sign up to our twitter feed

Promotions