Gear Blog
You are looking at: Home : News & Gossip : Gear Blog

Inside The Ultimate Soft Shell

The North Face Kishtwar jacket wings in using new Power Shield Pro claimed to offer the perfect balance between breathability and weather protection.

Posted: 5 July 2010
by Jon

Standard look, but innovative new fabric.


Inside the Kishtwar.

The nice man from UPS turned up this morning with the first Polartec Power Shield Pro garment we've got our sticky mitts on, a new for this autumn 2010, award-winning North Face Kishtwar Jacket.

Polartec's standard Power Shield has been around for ages, it's a perforated, PU membrane fabric that has a great balance between wind and weather protection - 95% wind proof is the claim - and breathability making it one of our favourite soft shell fabrics, but the new Power Shield Pro is something else again.

The word from Polartec is that it's pretty much waterproof with a hydrostratic head of 5000mm, but also genuinely vapour permeable, so it has better moisture vapour transfer rates - the thing that normally gets called 'breathability' – than competitors.

Blocks 99% of the wind...

The swing tag on our Kishtwar says that it 'blocks 99% of the wind' as well as being 'water repellent', the idea is that the remaining 1% allows air to circulate and thus improves breathability and reduces heat build-up. Interesting stuff and all part of the 'protection versus breathability' nexus at the heart of soft shell, er, or something like that. The membrane, if you want to get technical, is a PU, micro-porous one and remains water repellent for life to a minimum of 3,000mm while .

Outwardly the Kishtwar is a pretty standard looking soft shell in regulation black with neat, contrasting, green zips that you'll either like or not. Fit is nice and close and you get an adjustable hood and two harness-friendly chest pockets plus adjustable hem and cuffs.

The fabric, which is the interesting bit, is thin and stretchy with a backing that looks woven and not unlike the inside of a three-ply waterproof fabric. Weight for our medium test jacket is a real 550 grammes, which is reasonably light. And interestingly, we've already noticed that it doesn't have that instant, slight clamminess that you get with Windstopper garments on a warm day.

The Kishtwar isn't seam sealed, so like Gore Windstopper Soft Shell garments, it will eventually let water in at the joins, but should cope with snow, short bursts of medium rain, light rain, melting ice falls and the like.

Head To Head With Windstopper?

Polartec wouldn't say this directly, but reading between the lines, the obvious rival is Gore's Windstopper Soft Shell and the inference is that the new Power Shield Pro is more breathable while offering similar levels of protection – Windstopper too is effectively waterproof.

That's interesting because we've always found that Windstopper works best in cold, dry, alpine conditions, but struggles in the damper UK environment, though lots of venting makes it more useable.

In other words, Power Shield Pro could offer Windstopper-type protection but with enough extra breathability to cope with higher levels of exertion and/or warmer, more humid conditions, so it may work a whole lot better in the UK. Or then again, it might not.

We'll let you know how we get on. The North Face Kishtwar will be in the shops from this autumn with a serious price tag of around £239. Lowe Alpine also has a jacket made from Power Shield Pro, the, erm, Power Shield Pro Jacket we told you about a few months back, which may be taped or partially taped, we're not quite sure which.

There's more about the new fabric at www.polartec.com and more about the current TNF range at www.thenorthface.com

Previous story
Big Shake Out And Cliffhanger This Weekend
Next story
Houlding And Anker Everest Film Out Soon


The North Face, Polartec, Power Shield Pro
TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle


Discuss this story

Really annoying this. Its close to being comfortably the most breathable waterproof shell ever. But the seams, the seams....

The only reason I can think of for that piece of seeming willful sabotage is that they simply can't seam seal the fabric. Which would be a shame.

The extra technical info from the PDF linked to is interesting - the CFM is 2 vs 7 for standard powershield and about 4ish for a standard windshirt. So certainly giving something up in comfort terms.

Viewed from the perspective of a waterproof fabric, the HH is slightly/somewhat disturbing - they're admitting that it will degrade from its initial 5k to 3k but then mantaining it won't go any lower.

I wonder if there is any logic behind that. With them quoting 2.1k the lower limit for seam sealing its a little bit worrying.....
(standard waterproof fabrics have much bigger HH values.).

Also I suppose a question as to whether a properly vented 3 layer shell won't get close to this level of moisture transfer much of the time.

Posted: 05/07/2010 at 15:12

I think they can seal the seams, certainly the Lowe Alpine jacket has some sort of seam sealing, though when I saw it in March, it was a proto and unclear how the final version would be made. I wonder if the observations you make about hydrostatic head are the reasons it's not seam sealed... If it were, it would be a waterproof, as it is, it's a highly water resistant softshell and any sort of degradation in waterproofing is less crucial. Or maybe that's a little cynical.

Posted: 05/07/2010 at 18:38

You could buy some iron-on seam seal tape from Pennine Outdoor or Point North, at 90p/m, and tape the seams yourself...

See this article for details...

As an aside, I spotted an interesting Regatta jacket in TKMaxx at the weekend, the W's Cayley softshell (that link is even cheaper than TKM...).  It had a nice, soft handle, peached outer fabric, taped seams and claimed to be a membraned fabric, but you could blow air though it.

Here's the Regatta details.  Which confirm the quoted TKM rrp...


Posted: 05/07/2010 at 19:07

See more comments...
Talkback: Inside The Ultimate Soft Shell

First Name:
Last Name:
Nickname:
Email:
Security Image:
Enter the code shown:

I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct:

Latest news

New Review: Haglöfs Ambo Long Shorts
Latest OM site review is the new Haglöfs Ambo Shorts, long,...
Friday Matinee - Biking Special
Watch the entire new Anthills film Strength In Numbers for...
Weekend Mountain Weather Outlook
OM's unexpurgated interpretation of this weekend's mountain...
Cool Summits Everest Again With Medal
'Everest Like An Amusement Park' - Moro