I always carry back up, but it is somewhat minimal. A small self printed map and small compass.
I actually think the scope for losing the use of a paper map and compass is just as great. Anything from the map blowing away, breaking the compass or even just very thick fog.
Admittedly most of these can be negated somewhat with due care and preparation, but so can the issues with GPS.
I sometimes thing GPS gets a bad rap just because it's new or seen as "lazy". For me navigation is a means to an end rather than an end in itself, and I find GPS with a live OS map is the quickest, easiest and most accurate way of navigating.
If reliability is vitally important then these days I would definitely recommend backup GPS if you primarily use map and compass, as I would recommend the opposite.
Posted: 12/11/2011 at 02:34