Suppose you're half way up a multi-pitch trad route. You're leading and find yourself underneath the crux with twenty metres of rope out beneath you. The gear on this pitch so far has been excellent but runs out a couple of metres beneath the crux. You can see there's no decent gear until a few metres past the crux. Question is: do you build a belay beneath the crux or push on past it?
(copied so I can see what I'm replying to)
If you build a belay at the crux, I'm then assuming there is NO more gear until afterwards, so nowhere to get an early runner in for the next pitch? I'm also assuming I'd have to lead the crux whatever (i.e. be it the finish of this pitch or the start of the next) and am not with anyone leading much harder than me who would find it a doddle.
In which case I'd carry on. Otherwise a fall immediately after the belay would put immense strain on the belay itself. Falling on the crux (a few metres up, and no gear) would mean a large fall factor with not much rope to absorb the impact. Falling at the same point with good runners below, and well above the belay, would mean loads of rope out from the bottom belay and a lower fall factor.
It's one of those situations where the heart is saying "shiiit I don't like this, let's stop here" and the head calculating fall factors and realising it's wiser to move on.
Posted: 31/03/2006 at 11:13