Experimental Vehicle Ban On Dales Lanes
Updated
Access for recreational motorised vehicles to some 'green lanes' in the Yorkshire Dales is to be limited to control erosion and pollution problems
Posted: 12 February 2002
by Jon
Motorcycles and recreational 4x4 vehicles will be banned from four
'green lanes' in the Yorkshire Dales this summer as part of an
experimental scheme to reduce their impact on the park.
Experimental Traffic Regulation Orders are to be introduced by
North Yorkshire County Council in conjunction with the Dales Park
Authority, which lobbied for a total ban on recreational motor
vehicle use under the new Countryside and Rights of Way Act.
The regulations will take effect in the summer after a two-part
consultation process designed to allow all park users to have a say.
The four routes haven't yet been chosen, but the Park Authority told
OUTDOORSmagic that the most important consideration will be
'protecting quiet enjoyment'. That means routes in otherwise peaceful
areas are prime candidates, while other criteria will include the
'sensitivity' of routes, for example, those crossing an SSSI are more
likely to be closed and erosion considerations.
Motor vehicles cause major damage to unsurfaced tracks in the
area, which although technically roads, were never designed to be
used by modern powered off road transport. Anyone who has walked or
cycled on the notorious Mastiles Lane will appreciate just how
serious the problem has become. But the major consideration in the
Dales, is how motorised vehicles impinge on other's appreciation of
the countryside.
'Walkers, cyclists and horse riders all come out to the National
Park to appreciate its special qualities, its natural beauty and
peace,' says Steve Macaré, chairman of the Yorkshire Dales
National Park Authority. 'This is increasingly being compromised by
recreational motor vehicles and as an Authority we need to look at
solutions to the problem.'
Apparently complaints to the police about recreational vehicle use
are 'on the up' and this is 'by far the most contentious recreational
issue in the National Park at the moment.'
Although the Dales Park Authority would undoubtedly like to ban
4x4s and trail bikes from the area altogether, responsibility for
'green lanes' and other motorised rights of way rests with the County
Council who would ultimately have to take the decision. Expect a lot
of furious 4x4 users and trail bikers in the Dales soon.
Discuss this story
Should all 4x4s and trail bikes be banned from 'green lanes' period or is it just the thin end of a wedge that would eventually see us all get banned from the outdoors period? Prejudice or principle? Should we tolerate recreational motorised vehicles because they have a legal right to be there, or are they simply unsuitable for unsurfaced tracks?
Posted: 13/02/2002 at 14:36
I think that banning all motorised vehicles would be the start of massive restriction. Unfortunatly there are pressure groups that shout louder than any one else for their own cause and don't seem to think that people should be doing anything that may spoil their enjoyment of life. 4x4's and trail bikes would go first, then mountain bikers would be targeted, then horse riders until only the ramblers are left! Nope, I think that some restrictions need to be in place to protect sensitive areas, but the 4x4 brigade should be directed to areas that they can mud plug to their hearts content in! Everything causes erosion, it's just a case of directing it to areas that can cope with it. This should apply to some extent to everything from vehicles to people to sheep. Or maybe not....
Posted: 13/02/2002 at 15:17
I don't really know enough about the effects that vehicles have on green lanes (ie how much more erosion they cause than horses, bikes etc) to be able to make an unprejudiced judgement one way or the other. But a blanket ban doesn't sound like the way forward. Once motor vehicles are banned, how long will it be before mountain bikes, horses and people wearing Walshes are targeted? Its up to EVERYONE that enjoys the outdoors to do so responsibly, and I don't think that we should support a ban on other recreational users, rather we should encourage responsible use in suitable areas. Si
Posted: 13/02/2002 at 15:39
See more comments...
|